Skip to main content

Coaxial vs Component Car Speakers: Which Should You Buy?

Key takeaways
  • Coaxial speakers mount the tweeter on the woofer, so they drop into the factory holes. They are the easy, affordable upgrade.
  • Component speakers split the woofer, tweeter and crossover. That allows better tweeter placement and usually better sound, but the fitting takes more work.
  • Match the speakers to your stereo: with a factory radio look for sensitivity above 90 dB, and with an amplifier check the RMS power rating.

Swapping the factory speakers is one of the most worthwhile car audio upgrades, and the first choice you face is the type. Coaxial and component speakers both fit the same door openings, but they behave differently once they are installed. Here is how to pick the right one for your car.

What is the difference?

A coaxial speaker, also called a full range speaker, packs everything into one unit. The tweeter sits on top of the woofer, and a small built in filter sends the highs to the tweeter. A component set separates the parts: a woofer, a separate tweeter and an external crossover that splits the signal so the woofer gets the lows and the tweeter gets the highs.

Why component speakers can sound better

The main advantage is where the tweeter can go. High frequencies are directional, so a tweeter mounted higher up, on the door corner, the A pillar or the dash, points closer to your ears. That tends to give clearer vocals and a wider soundstage than a tweeter sitting low in the door. The separate crossover also divides the frequencies more cleanly between the two drivers.

If your car already has factory tweeters, the new ones can often go in the same position, which keeps the work simple.

Which one is easier to fit?

Coaxial speakers win here. The old speaker comes out, the new one goes in, and a wiring adapter keeps the job reversible. A component set needs a few more steps: mounting the woofer and tweeter separately, finding a dry, secure place for the crossover, and routing extra wiring through the door. Tweeters can be flush mounted, surface mounted or fitted in the factory location, and some come with angle mounts so you can aim them slightly.

Match the speakers to your stereo

Two numbers matter. Sensitivity tells you how loud a speaker plays for a given amount of power. With a low powered factory radio, which often delivers around 10 to 15 watts RMS per channel or less, look for sensitivity above 90 dB. With an aftermarket stereo or an amplifier you can use speakers with lower sensitivity.

RMS power handling tells you how much continuous power the speaker can take. Ignore the peak figure. With a factory radio, a low RMS rating is fine. With an aftermarket stereo and no amplifier, keep it at or below about 75 watts RMS. If you add an amplifier, match the speaker RMS rating to the amp output in its manual.

So which should you choose?

  • Choose coaxial if you want a simple, affordable improvement over worn factory speakers, you are fitting them yourself, or you want to keep the job easy to undo.
  • Choose component if sound quality and stereo imaging matter most, you are comfortable mounting tweeters and a crossover (or paying a fitter), and you plan to add an amplifier.

Do not skip the basics

Check the speaker size and mounting depth for your car before you buy, because a speaker that is too deep can hit the window mechanism. New speakers also work best in a quiet door, so a little damping goes a long way. If your sound is already distorting, fix the cause first.

Sources

Related reading

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Car Stereo IPod Transmitter

You have just found out that you need to go cross country, and you most definitely aren't flying there. This means that you will need to be taking a very long drive, which if you plan it just right, could become your vacation from work. The only things that you will need to make this an enjoyable trip will be your iPod, and your car stereo iPod FM transmitter. With one of these, you will find that you have no need of taking along your iPod car kit with you. Everything that you need will be in this one little gadget. That is of course, if you buy the car stereo iPod transmitter which also functions as an iPod charger. Otherwise you might also want to think about taking along your iPod charger as well! You will only need to take along a separate iPod charger if you have the wireless car stereo iPod FM transmitter. If you get one of the car stereo iPod transmitters complete with wires and therefore with a charger as well, you will find that life has became a whole lot easier. Now, ins...

What Is A Car Subwoofer?

What Is A Car Sub Woofer? Do you know what a car subwoofer is? Would you like to find out? In essence it is a speaker not in a box enclosure ( although they can and are often put in boxes ) with extra power running to it courtesy of an amplifier. The purpose of a car sub woofer is to deliver low frequency bass sounds in the music being played. Usually the octaves consistently delivered by sub woofers are missing from normal range car audio systems with speakers. Some music is specially created specifically for bass and are commonly known as bass tracks. Not All Car Subwoofers Are The Same: Basically subwoofers are of either a passive or powered type. A passive subwoofer setup will get its' power from the car audio system. A powered type of setup will get its power delivered independently of the car audio system being used. Car subwoofers are commonly put into box enclosures that they are mounted on and then placed into a suitable place in the car which is usually the boot area. Car...

Helix Power Station XXL Competition

As a state-of-the-art power stabiliser, the Helix Power Station XXL Competition enables the computerised stabilisation of the power amplifier input voltage with a digital display for the input and output voltage. The car battery thus becomes the world’s best power supply for the car hi-fi equipment and is even clearly superior to the electricity system at home. Aside from a perfect voltage stabilisation, that can, by the way, be simply adjusted by turning a potentiometer, the Helix Power Station offers a series of significant key features: The car battery is reliably protected from undervoltage – if the battery voltage drops below 10V for more than one minute, the Power Station switches off automatically. Due to its charge and discharge function, the outputs can be de-energized for maintenance. The integrated temperature monitoring provides additional safety during operations. The function of connected equipment is monitored with IMS technology (Integrated Managing Software). The separ...